Can a no-deal Brexit still happen?

Parliament and EU flagImage copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Boris Johnson is at odds with Parliament on the issue of leaving the EU without a deal

Boris Johnson has repeatedly said the UK is leaving the EU on 31 October. However, should the PM fail to strike a Brexit deal by 19 October, a law passed by MPs says the PM must extend the deadline.

So what exactly is this law and how might the government try to get round it?

What does the Brexit extension law say?

In September MPs passed a new law – introduced by Labour’s Hilary Benn – designed to stop Mr Johnson pushing through a no-deal Brexit on 31 October.

Under the “Benn Act”, Mr Johnson would be required to request a three-month Brexit delay unless he can pass a deal or get MPs to approve a no-deal exit by 19 October.

However, despite the new law, International Trade Secretary Liz Truss insists Brexit will still happen at the end of the month:

“We’ll leave without a deal. That’s clear – deal or no deal, we’re leaving on the 31st”, she told the BBC.

So what possible options might the government be looking at?

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Labour MP Hilary Benn’s bill sets the length of any further extension to three months

Two letters

The law would force the prime minister to request the extension via a letter – it even sets out the exact wording.

One idea that has been floated is for Mr Johnson to follow the rules but write a second letter, telling EU countries that he actually does not want an extension.

This could lead EU countries to decide not to grant the extension as it would be clear it is not what the UK government actually wants.

In this scenario it is possible the EU could simply ignore the second letter and just grant the extension.

Persuade someone to reject

Any extension to the Brexit deadline would have to be agreed to by all EU member states. So, theoretically, Mr Johnson could comply with the law by writing the letter, but persuade just one country to veto it.

Image copyright
PA Media

Image caption

Boris Johnson would be required to send a letter to Donald Tusk

But persuading a country to side with the departing UK over their European neighbours could be a long shot.

MPs vote for no deal or reject an EU extension

The prime minister would avoid having to send any letter if MPs vote in favour of a no-deal Brexit by 19 October. This is almost impossible as there is no majority in Parliament for this.

In another scenario, the EU grants an extension but proposes a date other than 31 January 2020. If that happens, MPs would have the power to reject the proposal, therefore leaving us heading towards a no-deal exit.

Image copyright

Image caption

An election is on the cards but the prime minister would still have the power to choose the date

Ignore the law and wait for the courts

The most simple option for the prime minister is to sit on his hands and refuse to write a letter. This would almost certainly lead to legal action and constitutional experts have suggested he would face almost certain defeat.

Mr Johnson could bank on the legal process taking over 12 days to complete, which would take him past the Brexit deadline before being forced to ask for an extension,

Refuse to resign

One option open to MPs who oppose a no-deal Brexit is to defeat the government in a vote of no confidence. In this scenario, an alternative government could emerge and take over from Mr Johnson if it can prove it has the confidence of a majority of MPs.

By convention, Mr Johnson would visit the Queen to resign and recommend the appointment of whoever the leader of the alternative government is.

In theory, he could refuse to leave and become a squatter behind the black door of No 10. This could put the Queen in an unprecedented position as she may be forced to sack him.

Please upgrade your browser

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *